Pa. Senate Passes School Choice Bill

The Pennsylvania State Senate, yesterday, Oct. 26, passed SB 1, 27-22 sending it to the State House.

The vote was mostly along party-lines in the Republican-controlled institution with Democrat Daylin Leach (D-17) leading the opposition with claims that the bill will take money from poor school districts. He failed to note, however, that the money taken will then been given to the families of the poor children. He attempted to add an amendment prohibiting private schools from discriminating due to sexual orientation. It failed.

Democrat Sen. Anthony Hardy Williams, however, who represents the 8th District which consists of a large section of southwest Philadelphia and a large section of southeast Delaware County, made an impassioned defense of the bill

Republicans who voted against the bill were Stewart Greenleaf of the 12th District; Lisa Baker of the 20th District;  John Gordner of the 27th District; Pat Vance of the 31st District; and Elder Vogel of the 47th District.

Democrats who voted for the bill were Williams; LeAnna Washington of the 4th District; and Andy Dinniman of the 19th District.

Not voting was Republican John Pippy of the 37th District.

The bill offers vouchers ranging from $5,765 to $13,905 to families with incomes of $29,000 whose children attend the 5 percent worst performing schools in the state that would allow them to  transfer their children to private or parochial schools. In the second year, the vouchers would also be offered to low-income students already attending private schools.

The bill also raises of the limit on the Educational Improvement Tax Credit (E.I.T.C.) from $75 million to $100 million for next two school years to $125 million for  2014-2015. Children from middle class families in all school districts are eligible for  E.I.T.C. scholarships.

Gov. Tom Corbett will almost certainly sign the bill if the House should pass it.

 

4 thoughts on “Pa. Senate Passes School Choice Bill”

  1. You can bet that Stewart Greenleaf of the 12th District; Lisa Baker of the 20th District; John Gordner of the 27th District; Pat Vance of the 31st District; and Elder Vogel of the 47th District, the Republicans who voted against the bill will get a heavy campaign contribution from the deep-pocketed teachers’ union.
    Shame!

  2. Right. It’s Ok for voucher scammers (people will make money from vouchers) to buy Anthony William’s vote, but the teachers can’t donate to politicians. Vouchers suck money from public school districts and have no proven result. Get a clue dude.

  3. The teachers union is not the only organization to come out against SB1. Many of the tea party and other conservative group, also opposed SB1 for a much different reason than the teachers union. Their opposition was based on the fact that SB1 is an entitlement program aimed at low income families (most do not even pay taxes) allowing their children to receive vouchers to attend private schools while those children whose parents struggle to get out of poverty, living in the same failing school district, will have to remain in the failing school. This is nothing more than redistribution of wealth. The same people who condemn the Obama administration for their redistribution philosophy supported SB1. Money does speak and $7,000,000 was put in PA to get this bill passed. A more equitable bill was introduced in the house by Curt Schroder. This bill would have made vouchers available to all students within the failing district, but according to senator Pileggi that bill was dead on arrival. SB1 has nothing to do with bettering education as the failing schools remain intact and students are still left behind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.