Charlie Alexander’s Case In Commonwealth Court

Charlie Alexander’s Case In Commonwealth Court — Greg Stenstrom’s article describing the state of Charlie Alexander’s crusade through the courts is below.

Charlie was kicked off the May 20 GOP primary ballot for County Council in Delaware County, Pa., after the party challenged his filing.

This was after he gathered 1,500 signatures which was six times the number needed.

The challenge was based on an improper filing of his financials. Charlie was not trying to hide anything. His disqualification was due to an easily correctable technicality.

We have made many of the the same points as Greg does in his article.

Pennsylvania’s ballot access laws are vague and complex on purpose. They are designed to disadvantage candidates who don’t meet establishment approval.

Change is needed.

Frankly, becoming an open primary state would not be a bad idea.

Yes, Charlie should be on the ballot.

Some are demanding to know Charlie’s specific sin.

Charlie attached his financial interest form to his petitions but failed to file it with the Delaware County clerk. This is an easily correctable mistake. He was obviously not trying to hide anything.

By Greg Stenstrom

In a sweeping challenge to what he calls “an abuse of election law and partisan weaponization of the courts,” Republican County Council candidate Charles E. Alexander filed a comprehensive appeal this week to the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania to overturn his unlawful removal from the May 2025 Primary Ballot and expose a systemic pattern of candidate suppression by political operatives in both the GOP and Democratic Party. His case, 386 CD 2025, now serves as the lead case exposing a systemic pattern of partisan interference and candidate suppression across Southeastern Pennsylvania.

“This case is about every American’s right to run for office and provide honest public service without the self-serving interference of party insiders and their misuse of the courts to decide elections before voters can,” said Alexander.

The filings allege that political attorneys representing both Republican and Democratic interests have coordinated to remove non-endorsed and grassroots candidates, exploiting minor technicalities and court procedures to disqualify candidates without due process.

Pattern of Suppression and Judicial Misconduct

Between March 18 and March 21, 2025, Delaware County Judge George A. Pagano issued orders removing Alexander from the ballot based on trivial paperwork defects in his Statement of Financial Interests. The petition was filed by attorneys closely aligned with party leadership, at the last possible moment before the challenge deadline, without notice or opportunity for Alexander to respond meaningfully. Judge Pagano ruled without providing factual findings, or a written opinion — contrary to established due process requirements.

Over 50 candidates in Delaware and Montgomery Counties have been similarly removed from ballots over the past two weeks, many without hearings, opinions, or procedural safeguards.

Alexander’s filings further reveal that political operatives and county solicitors appear to have solicited private petitioners as proxies to file last-minute challenges in coordination with party leaders, weaponizing the courts to control who appears on local ballots.

Emergency Appeal and Demand for Judicial Accountability

Alexander’s appeal demands that the Commonwealth Court:

1. Vacate the trial court’s orders and restore Alexander to the ballot immediately.

2. Issue a precedential opinion prohibiting candidate removals without written findings and hearings.

3. Investigate and disclose the partisan coordination behind these filings.

The appeal is supported by over two dozen filings, including Judicial Notices documenting that the same pattern of removals occurred in Montgomery County, where 42 candidates were struck from ballots under similar circumstances.

Alexander is being assisted by Gregory Stenstrom, a forensic computer scientist and elections integrity advocate who has been litigating and exposing election misconduct in Pennsylvania for four years.

“We are documenting a deliberate, systemic effort to suppress political competition through procedural trickery and misuse of the courts. If the courts refuse to protect constitutional rights, we will continue this fight to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and federal courts,” said Stenstrom.

Documented Pattern of Candidate Suppression and Key Findings from Court Filings:

Alexander’s filings include detailed Judicial Notices revealing:

• In Delaware County, 12 ballot objection cases were filed between March 13–25, 2025. 10 candidates were removed, 1 withdrew, 1 prevailed. Judges Pagano and Whelan presided over all cases.

• In Montgomery County, 42 separate objection cases were filed between March 18–27, 2025. 100% of challenged candidates were removed. Every case was decided by President Judge Carolyn Carluccio.

• In both counties, all removed candidates were non-endorsed, grassroots, or outsider candidates. Not a single endorsed party candidate was removed.

• The objections were filed by a small circle of politically connected attorneys closely affiliated with county committees and party leadership.

“These are not isolated technical errors,” said Stenstrom. “They are deliberate, coordinated efforts to keep political outsiders off the ballot and deny voters a choice.”

Public Access to Court Filings

All filings, Judicial Notices, and supporting documents are available for public review at:

https://cloud.patriot.online/s/XWsqXCQjfenjDKx

Judicial Notices on Systemic Candidate Removals:

• Delaware County:

https://cloud.patriot.online/s/jtpnaMXA43yY4TP

• Montgomery County:

https://cloud.patriot.online/s/2KK5d6srn29GFFk

The case underscores the urgent need for transparency and accountability in Pennsylvania’s candidate qualification process. Members of the public, journalists, and elected officials are encouraged to review the filings and demand answers as to why courts and county officials are participating in systematic exclusion of candidates without meaningful public notice, process, or justification.

Charlie Alexander's  Case In Commonwealth Court

Pennsylvania GOP Loses Safe Seat; Wake Up Delco

Pennsylvania GOP Loses Safe Seat; Wake Up Delco — The Pennsylvania GOP, yesterday, March 26, lost a state senate seat it had held since 1978.

Democrat James Malone beat Republican Josh Parsons in the 36th District in Lancaster County by 482 votes which was a margin of less than 1 percent.

Trump won the district by 17 points.

Parson was a Lancaster County commissioner.

The seat had been held by Ryan Aument who resigned to become  become the state director for Dave McCormick who just won a seat to the US Senate.

We have written about Aument.

It’s like we saw it coming.

Pennsylvania Republican leaders better wake up.

Same old, same old is not going to work.

The wake up better start in Delaware County, where the GOP is about to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

It orchestrated the removal of a fellow — who let us note we did not and do not plan to back — who had indisputable widespread support.

The removal was done in the hackish fashion that we have long despised.

This BS, by the way, can no longer be hidden.

And the people sure as sugar don’t like it.

The stupidity was compounded by a crowing statement dissing the fellow’s supporters followed by a mocking meme.

We’ll further note that we like Delco’s GOP leadership. We think Chairman Frank Agovino, Dave Galluch, Michael Straw and Rob Jordan are decent guys despite the attacks on them. We are convinced that they are honest and mean well.

The buck stops with the leadership, though, which means the division is the leadership’s fault.

We encourage Delco’s Republican leaders to reach out quickly to the other side. Start with Leah Hoopes and Greg Stenstrom.

Leah and Greg have legitimate grievances with the Delco GOP. They were abandoned when they spoke out in 2020 after the presidential election which caused them tremendous personal suffering.

We also suspect they will mistrust any peace offering. We are convinced, however, they will listen to reason as their goals are sincere and anything but mercenary.

The GOP bosses don’t have to concede every one of their points, either. They must, however, concede that they have points.

Really, Frank, when the Dems tried to change the law to pack the Election Board, don’t ya kinda think it was maybe even just a little red flag?

And why haven’t you made an issue of the Democrat-controlled council’s unwillingness to accept rulings by the Pennsylvania Office of Open Records to release certain election records?

Making that an issue would flip the “election denier” argument right back on them.

Why aren’t they trying to stop the widespread skepticism, after all?

This is a winnable election.

Even registered Democrats want easy access to hospitals, which is looking to be no longer the case in Delco.

Nobody wants 24 percent tax hikes to fund incompetence, corruption and stupidity.

We are writing in Sharon Devaney for County Council, May 20, then voting for the GOP ticket in November.

We aren’t confident that it’s going to do much good.

The one thing that gives us hope is Meaghan Wagner who is running for Register of Wills against Vinnie Rongione.

She seems to know how to fight.

Maybe she’ll carry the rest of them.

Pennsylvania GOP Loses Safe Seat; Wake Up Delco
At least Meaghan Wagner knows how to fight. She’s coming for you Vinnie.

Charlie Off Ballot In Delco

Charlie Off Ballot In Delco — The Delaware County (Pa) Republican Party has successfully removed Charlie Alexander of Marple from the ballot for the May 20 primary election.

Despite Charlie getting 1,500 petition signatures for the County Council race.

The challenge concerned the filing of a financial statement.

It was likely an inadvertent misreading of requirements and easily corrected.

Those who enforce the election code are notorious for their insistence on obeying every jot and tittle of it.

At least for those who run against the establishment.

We are not fans of Charlie and we are confident that he would have fairly lost to party-endorsed Liz Piazza and  Brian Burke.

It remains, however, an extremely boneheaded move by GOP leaders which they have compounded with a crowing statement dissing Charlie’s supporters, most of whom are honest, very hard working activists and wonderful people.

You know, the kind you want on your side.

We plan on writing in Sharon Devaney and then backing the GOP ticket for the general as it is about the only way of saving Delco from the mind-blowing corruption that effuses the county Democrats like odor from a rock-concert port-a-potty.

We’d also like to point out that we generally like GOP Chairman Frank Agovino and his leadership team. We have no plans to pile on other than to point out that they really screwed up here.

Charlie Off Ballot In Delco
Charlie Alexander and Sharon Devaney in more peaceful times. Unity is necessary to save Delco
Charlie Off Ballot In Delco
Crowing was unwise. Charlie got 1 percent of Delco’s registered GOP voters to sign his petition without much help. Only a bonehead would think an election can’t be decided by 1 percent.

GOP Gives Boneheaded Challenge To Charlie’s Petition

GOP Gives Boneheaded Challenge To Charlie’s Petition — Charlie Alexander X-posted, last night, March 18, that the Delaware County Republican Party is challenging his petition for the May 20 primary alleging he incorrectly filed the required financial statements with the county.

This is mind-blowing stupidity by the GOP.

We think stupid games are unnecessary for party-endorsed Liz Piazza and  Brian Burke to beat Charlie.

And a loss by Charlie means that the sore-loser law takes effect preventing him from a third-party run

It might even mean a better outcome.

Treating Charlie with a little respect might even garner his support.

If Charlie should win, of course, it means the people will have spoken and no party can win without its people.

Charlie says he got 1,500 signatures That is 1,250 more than required.

When candidates do the things of which Charlie is accused, it is invariably an innocent misreading of unnecessarily complex and arcane legalese, and easily correctable.

This game playing is only going to cause the many people in this county who think like Charlie to stay home and the GOP will lose a very winnable election.

Even if Charlie doesn’t run as an independent.

And for the record Charlie, Sharon Devaney was never in any secret meetings with the Republican Party.

GOP Gives Boneheaded Challenge To Charlie's Petition
When Charlie had a beard

GOP Gives Boneheaded Challenge To Charlie’s Petition

Following Pennsylvania’s Unendorsed Judicial Candidates

Following Pennsylvania’s Unendorsed Judicial Candidates

By Bob Small

Two of the judicial candidates who were not endorsed, Feb. 8 by the Pennsylvania GOP are continuing their campaigns.

Maria Battista is still in the Superior Court race and Joshua Prince continues his quest for a seat on Commonwealth Court.

Commonwealth Court  was established in 1968 and and Superior Court in 1895. They are Pennsylvania’s intermediate appellate courts.

For a not too detailed analysis see Pennsylvania Court Structure

Maria Battista was a hearing examiner for three years, among many other postings.

In a Q and A with the Legal Intelligencer, she noted she a bachelors from Clarion University, Juries Doctorate from Ohio Northern University, masters in business Administration from Westminster College and a Docorate of Education from the University of Pittsburgh.

Recently, she has worked for the Pennsylvania Coalition of Nurse Practitioners.

Josh Prince heads the Joshua Prince – Civil Rights Defense Firm, P.C.

He is a cumlaude graduate of Montreal’s McGill University and the Harrisburg branch of Widener School of Law. His law firm focuses on Civil Rights law — such as unlawful seizure and Covid mandates, and Second Amendment issues.

His Endorsemne tpage includes six state representatives, a congress member, three county officials and a a representative of the Second Amendment Foundation.

He is married to Jessica.

The endorsement meeting is where state Sen. Greg Rothman beat businessman Bill Bachenberg to be become state GOP chairman.

“The Swamp may have won today but the MPGA and MAGA movement can’t be stopped. The PA GOP establishment has awoke a pride of sleeping tigers, stay tuned,” Bachenberg said.

Following Pennsylvania's Unendorsed Judicial Candidates

Following Pennsylvania’s Unendorsed Judicial Candidates

GOP Gets Primary Race For Delco Council

GOP Gets Primary Race For Delco CouncilLiz Piazza and Charlie Alexander say they have more than enough signatures to be on the ballot for the May 20 Republican primary election.

They seek the Democrat-held seats on Delaware County, Pa., Council that are being vacated by corporatist Kevin Madden and contested by incumbent Richard Womack.

Liz is endorsed by the Delco GOP.

Charlie, not so much.

Also in the race is Upper Darby Council President Brian Burke, also endorsed by the GOP. We expect the shooting, however, to be almost entirely between Charlie and Liz.

Challenges to Charlie’s petitions are expected. He appears confident, though, that he has the 250 needed to be on the ballot.

We are staying out of it and writing in Sharon Devaney.

The Democrats have endorsed county Controller Joanne Phillips to replace Madden.

GOP Gets Primary Race For Delco Council
We are writing in Sharon. She doesn’t bow before guys at the Home Depot.

GOP Gets Primary Race For Delco Council

Losers Alienate Allies; Winners Don’t

Losers Alienate Allies; Winners Don’t — Our political advice for today is don’t alienate allies.

Actually, the smart ones who seek office don’t merely keep their friends during disagreements but turn their former opponents into friends.

There does seem to be some very stupid people seeking office in Delaware County, Pa.

The universal issue is the ever-growing tax burden caused by corruption and greed. Much of what the Democrats have been spending since they took over has been going to places it doesn’t belong.

Really, why else would they have appointed a man as register of wills under whose watch money in municipal bank accounts was not what had been expected in Upper Darby?

This corruption should be enough for a change if the public is properly informed.

Will they be?

That’s something worth pondering.

There are other issues, however, that would also strike a chord should they enter the converstation.

Consider illegal immigration. One fellow who was very good on the issue — he actually made his name on it — told the The Philadelphia Inquirer that it is not a priority as it is handled by the feds.

What’s up with that, Charlie? The County wasn’t setting disturbing policies, after all?

Or are you now “strategizing” like the political hacks we’ve come to hate?

And then there is election integrity, an important issue that might not have much traction in the general population.

There are those, however, who know how critical it is, and that very simple things can be done to make Delco’s elections much more secure. Start by firing Election Director Jim Allen. Then ask why Delco fights rulings by the state Open Records Office regarding election records. Finish up by questioning why Dems don’t seem concerned by the failures of the neato election tech gizmos they adopted.

Actually, they can also ask why the County is so intent on enlarging precincts and why poll watchers don’t have the rights at the central ballot counting center as they do at traditional precincts.

Actually these issues can get traction with the proper promotion.

But these aren’t being talked about. What’s happening is that a certain segment is now attacking those who refuse to bow before them and sprinkle them with holy water.

Why? Hurt feelings? A smart candidate will understand that it’s he who is supposed to have thick skin and it is up to him to make sure feelings of potential supporters are not hurt.

C’est la vie. It’s not happening.

Maybe the issue that upsets us the most in Delaware County is the tyranny and corruption concerning Delaware County Youth Services.

Charlie Alexander gave some powerful and personal testimony about what goes on there. Read it here.

So has Billy “Jack” Ruane, which can be found here.

You think maybe they might concentrate on the things they have in common.

Alternative Power And Nuclear Plants

Meaghan Wagner Pledges To Torment Rongione In Register of Wills Race

Meaghan Wagner Pledges To Torment Rongione In Register of Wills Race — The Delaware County Republicans, last night, Feb. 24 picked Liz Piazza as their second County Council endorsement and endorsed Upper Darby Councilwoman Meaghan Wagner for register of wills.

The GOP endorsed, Feb. 18, former Upper Darby Council President Brian Burke and Chester Upland School Director Tasliym Morales for the two County Council seats up for election.

Ms. Morales, however, stepped down after a social media smear campaign implying she supported DEI and was a closet Democrat.

She addressed party leaders, last night, with a generous and passionate plea for unity. She noted that the allegations against her were false and that her day job is in jeopardy due to her opposition to DEI.

Also addressing the leaders, was activist Charlie Alexander of Marple. He had earlier sought GOP endorsement for County Council but now said he wanted the GOP to make no primary endorsements and would reject one if given him.

Charlie made several good points about governance in his statement, though. He also noted how skillful use of social media can overcome financial disparity.

Also seeking the endorsement was Sharon Devaney of Springfield. The reasons why she was running can be found here.

Sharon got the votes from the party organizations of Swarthmore, Chester and Newtown.

Ms. Wagner’s statement was a sledgehammer against Democrat incumbent Vincent A. Rongione.

Rongione had been chief administrative officer of Upper Darby until he had to resign in disgrace in 2023. Municipal bank accounts were found far lower than they should have been. Ms. Wagner says the missing money was in the millions.

Rongione was appointed to the post a year later after incumbent Rachel Ezzell Berry stepped down to take a seat on Common Pleas Court.

Ms. Wagner said he was “punished up” as Democrats often do to those caught doing wrong.

She said she will enjoying spending the months through November — figuratively — kneeing Rongione in the groin.

Alternative Power And Nuclear Plants

Why I’m Running For Delco Council

Why I’m Running For Delco Council

By Sharon Devaney

I am running for Delaware County (Pa.) Council. Here is what I plan to say at tonight’s endorsement meeting for the Delaware County Republican party.

My start in politics concerned my kids and the Haverford public schools. Granted schools are not a County Council matter but this is when I became politically active circa 2014.

I was an Obama voter, by the way, and never supported a Republican until Donald Trump in 2016.

My rambunctious son was declared to have attention deficit disorder and they pushed hard to put him on meds. I objected. To my shock, I found myself pressured by the faculty and administration to the point where it reached intimidation and bullying. I held my ground, but parents rights were not what those running things respected.

I then became aware of books being assigned that were, to be polite, sexually inappropriate. They seemed like a grooming effort.

I again objected. To my still puzzlement the administration and staff dismissed my concerns. This was not an attempt to ban books from the library but a desire to see parents consulted and warned about curriculum.

One of the administrators with whom I most butted heads was the Haverford High vice principal. This man was eventually found putting sexualized photos of himself on Instagram where he was friends with many students.

He was defended by the administration until one Christmas when he published a photo of himself wearing only a Santa cap and Christmas lights.

He had to be let go, at this point. I understand, though, he found himself a nice job in public education in New Jersey.

The other issue for which I became a bit notorious was illegal immigration.

On April 10, 2017, I was taking my daughter to my parents before going to work when my Toyota was t-boned at Lawrence and Ellis roads. The other driver turned out to be an illegal immigrant. She did not have insurance or a drivers license. She never passed a drivers test. She was speeding. The police at the scene angrily told me they could do nothing due to policies created to protect those here illegally.

If this was you or I we would find ourselves intimately involved with the criminal justice system.

This woman escaped all consequence.

Thank God, she hit my side else my daughter would likely have been killed. As it is, I am crippled. I can no longer run. I fear walking on ice and using escalators. I almost always use the handicapped ramp.

What happened to me was not a one-off. I’ve heard from many who have had similar experiences about the unwillingness of law enforcement to arrest illegals.

I am not opposed to immigrants or anyone here legally, but what has been going on in this county is social suicide. Willfully ignoring the law is social suicide.

Regarding, the 2025 election the big issue is the massive property taxes imposed by the Democrat controlled council, and the big tax hikes coming in the next few years.

I think we all hope this wakes the citizens of Delco up and they demand a change.

Democrat Richard Womack is seeking re-election. He is a nice guy and he voted against the 23.8 percent tax hike his fellow Ds imposed on us.

Richard, however, was a rubber stamp for every wild spending project passed by council during his term and he does not deserve to be returned.

And we really don’t want Joanne Phillips of Middletown to be elected. She most certainly will continue the impoverishment of Delco’s middle and working classes.

Why I'm Running For Delco Council
Former High School Vice Principal Steven Quinn on Instagram

JOE Post Going Uncontested In Delco

JOE Post Going Uncontested In Delco — Media GOP Chairman Michael Straw has let us know that numerous extremely vital judge of election (JOE) posts are uncontested in Delaware County.

The Democrats, well socialists, who run the county fill the spots if no one is elected.

Just letting all patriots know.

It is a paid position and only 10 signatures are needed to get on a ballot. First day to file petitions are Feb. 18 and the deadline to submit them is March 11.

JOE Post Going Uncontested In Delco

JOE Post Going Uncontested In Delco